Senate Defeats Flag Amendment
The "Flag Desecration Amendment," which would amend the Constitution to give Congress the power to criminalize any "physical desecration" of the American flag, was narrowly defeated by the U.S. Senate in June. The measure failed by one single vote. The flag amendment is opposed by a broad spectrum of individuals encompassing conservative and progressive beliefs, including thousands of veterans, who fear the implications for basic American freedoms if the amendment were ratified. This amendment would restrict one of the very freedoms that the flag represents: freedom of speech. Though we as individuals are free to condemn those who would deface the flag, censorship has no place in the Constitution. With the margin so close in the Senate, we must continue fighting to defend the First Amendment against this unnecessary and dangerous attack.
This amendment would be the first restriction ever placed on our First Amendment right to free speech, using the flag as a vehicle to take away one of the very freedoms it represents.
This country is unique and special because the minority, the unpopular, the dissident also have a voice. The freedom of expression, even when it hurts, is the truest test of our dedication to the principles that our flag represents.
Many veterans who have faithfully served our country strongly believe that amending the Constitution to ban flag desecration is the antithesis of what they fought to preserve.
The flag burning amendment is a solution is search of a problem.
Historians have shown that in the 200 years between when the flag was adopted in 1777 and when Congress passed a flag burning law -- which was then rejected by the Supreme Court in 1989 --only 45 instances of flag burning had been reported. A measure of such magnitude to serve a purpose so petty is a glaring example of election-year politics trumping the true interests of the American people.